Outrageous Fortune by Patricia Wentworth – a Golden Age Gem

Image result for outrageous fortune wentworth

This Golden Age Mystery, originally published in 1933, now reprinted by the excellent Dean Street Press, is quite simply a splendid mystery. It is one of the best representations of women as actual characters in a crime novel I have read for a while, despite the slight tendency for them to overdose on the romantic elements. It is however the women of this novel who push forward the action at every turn, and provide the comic relief when things get very heavy. There is no “Miss Silver” to be found in this Wentworth novel, and no real detective; despite this the action is gripping as the main male character, Jim, tries to clear his memory and name. It is unusual, as there is a shortage of details of the crime, but this works as the protagonists attempt to achieve their desires and sort out a very confused and foggy picture.

The novel opens in a small hospital where a mystery man lies muttering about green beads and seems to have totally lost his memory of who he is and how he got there. He is quickly claimed by a woman called Nesta, who states that he is her husband, and she bears him off to be looked after by Tom, her brother, and his wife Min. As Jim regains full consciousness, he is amazed to discover that he is apparently married and the only person to know the whereabouts of a priceless emerald necklace, removed when its owner, Elmer Van Berg was shot.  A local man, he is discovered by his younger cousin Caroline who has always idolised him, and who is determined to help him solve the riddle of his imperfect memory. Incidentally, she lives with Pansy Ann, who provides an innocent diversion to the main story with her romantic life. The characters move around finding more clues to what actually happened, and this interesting, seemingly impossible situation is finally resolved.

There are sometimes when a well written mystery novel really is really addictive and enjoyable, and this one fits the bill well. Its unusual premise does require a certain suspension of disbelief at times, but the characters are well drawn in terms of a mystery novel of the period, and I enjoyed even those who utter dire threats and seem determined to gain their own ends. Both the misguided and the misinformed have their roles to play, and there are several classic elements of secrets and foggy memory which are brought into play here. Dean Street Press have found some real gems of this period and reprinted them to great effect. I was really pleased to receive a review copy of this book, and found it to be a really good read with few pretentions except to be an enjoyable mystery with no gore or disturbance but a really well worked out story. For those who enjoy Golden Age Mysteries, especially those looking for a book where the female characters are not in the background, I can thoroughly recommend this novel.

I have been quite quiet here for the last week as Guests and Book Sale have rather dominated life. I have also been manufacturing bunting (well, helping,) and writing invitations. I returned from said Book Sale with a box of books, but some were for Northernvicar and a young friend, honestly! I was most  excited to get a copy of “Letters of Note”, the large hardback edition, which I have looked at for some time. It is not a book to read from cover to cover but a lovely book to dip into, so watch this space for future quotes…

Back to Work – with an old mystery…

So I’ve been away again with no online connection, and let my blog drift. Most unprofessional. Just when I had got a few people in the habit of looking at this bizarre mix of books as well. Still, jaunting done for a bit, so I hope to be a bit more dedicated to the cause.And maybe even do some more regular posts…

Still, Son Two behaving himself at University, and even doing some work. Have discovered a book token type card that I can top up in any bookshop and he can use at any bookshop to buy expensive textbooks. It means I can effectively buy him his books without being present, and he tells me that they don’t accept it in pubs….It also means that I have a top up card at home, whereas he has a matching piece of plastic in whichever Northern town he happens to be in…. the wonders of modern technology.Look it up under “Student Book Card” at http://www.nationalbooktokens.co.uk . Thank you Daughter and her Bookshop Flatmate for the idea.

Anyway, lecture over. A book read while I was away

Patricia Wentworth was a contemporary of the Great Agatha, and like her often writes about an elderly woman detective. On the evidence of this novel The Traveller Returns by Patricia Wentworth these are less cosy murder mysteries, set during the Second World War. This novel features the mysterious Anne Jocelyn, believed killed in Occupied France, but now suddenly returned. Those closest to her are confused about her true identity, but secrets are disclosed that seem that only one answer is possible. It is only when Miss Silver, that redoubtable lady knitting away, encounters a doomed lady on a train that the stakes, already emotionally high, get even higher in an atmosphere of suspicion and distrust. Is Anne who she claims to be? Could she be an obscure cousin? A satisfactory conclusion seems elusive as Miss Silver tries to convince more than one person that murder with a cause has been committed.

This is a good, if a bit dated, murder mystery. Ideal for those who have read a lot of Christie (or watched it on the tv ) and want something a little more challenging in terms of plot and motive, but with the same sort of background. This is not a modern gory thriller, but well written and with some interesting twists. Easier to read than the Campion books (for hardcore historical mystery readers only, unless you watch the dvd box set with the lovely Peter Davidson in), but tougher than Christie, this is an ideal book for the roaring fire, chocolate/alcohol evening in. This book is probably best read in quite a short time, as it is pretty complex, unless you can keep everything in mind. A quick check on a certain website suggests that there are many of her books out there which can be acquired quite cheaply. But don’t blame me if you get hooked…