Containment by Vanda Symon – The return of Sam Shephard, police officer of New Zealand


This latest book in the Sam Shephard series is, like the others, a funny, brilliantly descriptive, well paced book with more than its fair share of drama. This book can be read as a standalone, as Sam is a character who tells her own story so well that it is soon easy to pick up the trail of events and her reactions. A young woman with a realistic but slightly grim way of looking at life, she runs a commentary about her colleagues, her friends and her family. Those involved with the stomach turning discovery of the body, though not graphically described, are an interesting bunch of characters, gradually introduced as Sam recovers from a dramatic attack. The variety of people in the area is fascinating, as a seaside resort and small town life collide. As a ship runs aground many people rush to loot the contents of containers which are washed ashore. Tracking down the people responsible and stuff stolen becomes quite a full time job, while Sam struggles with her family and boyfriend. Every character is given a full description in an economical way, and every relationship explained. I was so pleased to have the opportunity to read and review this novel. 


Sam is actually on a day off when she discovers a horrifying sight; a huge tanker is stranded on the beach and the contents of several containers are strewn across the land, with people in a frenzy. As she approaches some individuals to remonstrate with them, she receives a blow which flattens her.  She is rescued by a concerned bystander, but she soon becomes involved further with her attacker. A unfair allocation of work leads to her being present at the retrieval of a body which kicks off a murder case. Sam encounters some of those who knew the victim, and it transpires that they are quite the variety of people, some with rather dubious lifestyles. Fortunately, she is never easily shocked and takes a robust view of those who would otherwise find them difficult. Not that she finds life easy, with family concerns and romantic pressure.She discovers a lot about diving and  the distribution of allsorts of things, and makes some new aquaintances. Her relationship with her work colleagues is honest and frank, and shows real insight. The descriptions of the places that she visits are memorable, especially the student house which is very nearly indescribable! 


This is a mature and well written black comedy thriller with a strong female character in the lead, able to handle most situations. It presents a  fascinating picture of life in New Zealand, in all its recognisable small community life as well as its normally picturesque coastal setting. As with the other book in the series that I have read, Sam Shephard is a fantastic creation whose impulsive and courageous behaviour makes for exciting reading. Her sense of natural justice is strong and helps keeps the book moving along so well. I recommend this book to anyone who enjoys a lighter crime novel in a different setting, but with effortlessly familiar emotions.    


This seems a good time to mark International Women’s Day, with a book written by a woman featuring a female police officer. This is certainly not a “woman in peril” novel – if anything Sam is the only one who keeps her head while all around are losing theirs – to misquote a famous piece of poetry quite deliberately!

The Ringmaster by Vanda Symon Murder investigation in New Zealand, with a Circus to discover

The Ringmaster by Vanda Symon


The South Island of New Zealand is the setting for this powerful murder mystery, featuring the actions, attitudes and realisations of Sam Shephard. After a book evidently narrating her investigations into troubles in a small town, she has now moved to Dunedin, a bigger city with a University and a larger police department. For unknown reasons to Sam, as a young female detective constable, she has earned the antipathy of the bullying DI Johns, who is continually criticising and sidelining her. As this is a first person narrator, we discover how much Sam resents this, and how much her friends both in the force and out of it try to help her endure it. Written with both a keen sense of the dramatic and a sharp sense of humour, this is a novel in which twenty first century policing and relationships are shown in depth. There are some genuinely thrilling moments, as Sam’s farming background demonstrates that she has a toughness denied to city dwellers. There is complexity but also some funny sessions as Sam deals with parental pressures, romance and her friendships with Maggie and her colleagues in the police force. A relatively short novel which packs a real punch, Sam is a real hero in every sense. I was very glad to be given the opportunity to read and review this book as part of a blog tour.


The book opens with the murder of a young Phd student as she evidently places her trust in her killer. When Sam is called to the discovered body, her time guarding the crime scene awakens her curiosity, so her clever dealing with a protest at the newly arrived circus becomes a lesser concern. However, despite her evident abilities and courage she finds herself having to pick up from recordings of interviews what is going on in the investigation, and suddenly she becomes the focus of attention herself as her involvement with the circus forces her into much publicised action.  Alongside her dramatic professional life there are the drawbacks of city life, of parking and coming across other police officers in awkward circumstances. Her friendship with Maggie is the source of much of the undoubted humour of this book, and contributes to Sam’s professional survival in the face of her openly bullying boss. Fortunately, Sam’s strong personality and temper makes sure that she sometimes gets the better of the powers that be, and at least this reader had to suppress a quiet cheer at the brilliant replies that she comes up with when provoked.


This was a fast paced book with plenty of action and a good dollop of mystery. I enjoyed the female led action, and the ending really lived up to the rest of the novel. This is not a heavy read, yet very satisfying on many levels. No knowledge of New Zealand is needed, as many of the elements of this book are universal. It features a strong mystery, together with a fascinating investigation ambushed by the personal obsessions by some of the police. There are interesting observations on circuses, families and relationships. I really enjoyed reading it, and recommend it it as more than a murder mystery; it is a substantial mystery and satisfying read.  


Easter Monday, and the weather is still really good in this part of Britain.I hope wherever you have spent it you have had some time to read some good books!