Arabella by Georgette Heyer – a genuinely funny social romantic comedy of the Regency period

Arabella: Georgette Heyer Classic Heroines: Heyer ...


A beautiful young woman who becomes the toast of society in her season in London sounds like a standard subject for Heyer, but also being Heyer there is a twist in this social comedy romance. Arabella is the eldest daughter of a vicar and a his wife who, it is alleged, turned down several offers of marriage before they had a bevy of children. Amanda is the oldest daughter and it is hoped that when she accepts her godmother’s offer of a season in London she will receive an offer of marriage from a wealthy man which will help the family. The plot is basic, but the way that it is handled is very skilful and is covered with much humour and insight. Heyer is a genius in creating characters, and in Arabella and the hero, Robert Beaumaris, she has created two who defy expectations with style. The humour comes from Arabella’s determination to adopt helpless creatures and Beaumaris’ attitude to those who she concerns herself with throughout the novel. Arabella is not the most strident of Heyer’s heroines, but she is determined when she perceives wrong, and takes on people who she perceives to be cruel. Beaumaris is a man whose cynicism and confidence makes light of sticky situations, despite his impeccable sense of place and social necessities. There are lines here that are genuinely funny, elements that are touching, and characters whose speech alone is unintelligible even to those of the time, let alone now. Heyer’s sure touch with dialogue, situation and plot means that disaster can soon be averted, true love will overcome, and the Regency world is a secure place to plunge into through the pages of this novel. 


As the novel begins, Arabella is at home with her siblings and parents, revealing their strong personalities as they prepare for a great event, Arabella’s departure for London. Her mother is supportive, remembering her triumphs in her youth, pulling out dresses and accessories to be remodelled in the common cause. Arabella is charming, friendly and beautiful, and manages to get the most unlikely people on her side. When an unfortunate accident on her journey south occurs, she breaks her journey at a large house which belongs to Beaumaris. In order to boost her confidence and give herself a confidence she lacks, she pretends to be a wealthy heiress. This impresses his companion, Lord Fleetwood, who is also taken with her looks. He has already pointed out to Beaumaris that he has turned down every beautiful young woman on the marriage market, drawn not only by his considerable wealth but also his undoubted position as a leader of society. When Arabella reaches London, her godmother’s determination to launch her into society together with her acquaintance with Beaumaris makes her quite the attraction at the many social events they attend. 


Just how it is resolved is quite a triumph of Heyer’s art with people and life. Her research is impeccable and presented to great effect. This is a superb book for anyone who enjoys a Regency novel, and shows how Heyer can keep the reader guessing.   


For me, Georgette Heyer, and to a certain extent her later imitators represent the ultimate comfort read. When a lot of things shut down a friend handed me five of her books to keep me going as my collection of Heyer books bought years ago was inaccessible at the time. I have since discovered a double banked shelf of her books upstairs, and was considering trying to fill in the gaps when another shelf full emerged. Rest assured that I have quite a lot of Heyers to read before I get onto those who copied her. Do you have comfort reads? Are they like Heyer? 

20 thoughts on “Arabella by Georgette Heyer – a genuinely funny social romantic comedy of the Regency period

  1. Nice review. Did you notice a typo early on, you once refer to Arabella as “Amanda”. Have you also been reading Sprig Muslin?

    Comfort reads include Heyer, Angela Thirkell, D. E. Stevenson, Patricia Wentworth, Agatha Christie, Dorothy L. Sayers, Mary Stewart, Ellis Peters, Elizabeth Peters, and more.

    1. Whoops! No, Sprig Muslin is still to come! That list of comfort reads seems familiar! My addiction to Angela Thirkell is legendary! Ellis Peters and Elizabeth Peters are old friends, and I’ve even given a talk on DLS. How about Susanna Gregory? A bit obscure perhaps, but marvellous on medieval Cambridge.

  2. I wouldn’t dream of trying to put my GH’s in order of preference (I don’t get on with her mystery stories) but Arabella would be somewhere near the top. Partly because the heroine is so dauntless, partly because of the period detail, but also because of the family atmosphere portrayed at the beginning. Of course nowadays I identify with Mamma!

    Thanks for this review, Joules, as it has reminded me to read the book again – for perhaps the 20th time? Or more? Who’s counting? Never has middlebrow fiction been so valuable as this year, except possibly during WWII.

    1. Middlebrow fiction is just wonderful, an especially safe choice at the moment. Was it Heyer that said that she wrote books that people could enjoy in an air raid – not the same I know, but still helpful.

  3. When you run out of Heyer, if you can find them, try Barbara Metzger. Her regencies are very light hearted and occasionally paranormal (I’m fond of Miss Treadwell’s Talent,, and the True Love Trilogy is a hoot).

  4. Well Heyer would certainly be on my list of comfort authors. I used to binge read her books on a regular basis, favourites being Sylvester, Frederica, The Black Sheep, Bath Tangle and yes, Arabella. Other comfort authors, Terry Pratchett, Dana Stabenow, Ann McCaffrey, Angela Thirkell… I’m sure there are more.

  5. I love Heyer and yes, she’s a comfort read for me, along with the Three Investigators (I have an emergency pile of them) and pony books and triplets of novels about cafes in Cornwall! This is indeed one of the best, too. I have to climb over piles of tech stuff to get at mine but they are just about visible.

  6. I love Heyer’s Regency books and also her mysteries are well worth reading. Other comfort reads are Mary Stewart, D.E. Stevenson, Thirkell of course, Rosamunde Pilcher, Elizabeth von Arnim, Winston Graham and Penelope Lively.

  7. Never thought of Susanna Gregory, will have a go at her. Just reading Angela Thirkell’s Love Among the Ruins and loving the references to food which deserve a study on their own. Might bully someone into doing it …

  8. I have to ration myself with Georgette Heyer, she’s the comfort read par excellence. I think my favourite has to be Venetia, when happiness does genuinely appear to be at stake. But I would happily take any to my desert island.

    1. I do know what you mean about them being wonderful comfort reads. I certainly read quite a few in a few months of family crisis in 2008,and was borrowing them from many different people. That means I have very little idea of which ones I actually own!

    2. I absolutely agree with you, Gill. The only thing I haven’t done, which I keep intending to, is to check out the quotations in Venetia. Some writers like Angela Thirkell and Dorothy L. Sayers do lots of these but it is rarer in Heyer.

      1. I’m afraid my Greek is non-existent but from what I remember, the Latin quotations are all pretty fair and the biblical ones certainly hit the mark!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.